1/17 Warriston Street, Brighton, VIC

Inspection Info

Address

1/17 Warriston Street, Brighton, VIC

Guide

$2,400,000

Reviewed By

Jack Johnstone, Buyers Agent on July 14, 2026

Jack Johnstone

Buyers Agent

Ask a Question

First Impression

A genuinely unique Brighton offering that is unlike anything else currently on the market. The church conversion has been executed beautifully, with soaring ceilings, incredible character and quality finishes throughout. The Bay Street location is outstanding and the home will appeal to buyers looking for something with real personality rather than another generic townhouse. The challenge is that this is a niche product. We saw that when it last came to market, where it took longer than expected to find a buyer. The layout and style simply won't suit everyone, which naturally limits the buyer pool. For the right purchaser it's exceptional, but I'd expect it to divide opinion again.

Proximity to Bay St
High Ceilings

Body Corp
In a church can be polarising

Report Card

Buyers Agent

Jack Johnstone

Private Grading

Grade Here

Land Content

Building Condition

Natural Light

Privacy

Floorplan Internal Flow

Value Add

Neighbouring Properties

The Bottom Line

B+

Preliminary Grade

You have graded this

Jack Johnstone
BuyerX - Bayside

With more than a decade selling real estate in Melbourne’s prestigious Bayside market, Jack Johnstone brings a deep understanding of the local property landscape to BuyerX as Director of Bayside. Living in Brighton East and having spent most of his life in Bayside, Jack knows the area well beyond property prices. From understanding which streets fall within sought-after school zones, to recognising the subtle lifestyle differences between neighbourhoods, his knowledge helps clients make informed long-term decisions.

B+